About Royal Family Directory
The Saudi Royal Family Directory is the comprehensive source for biographic and geneological information on the Saudi Arabian Royal family. The database includes over 5,000 records of Saudi Royal family members. You can search the database and view the family tree for free. For online biographic reports, check out the subscription page.

Feature Article
2017-10-18

The Disaffected Princes: Danger From Within?

Despite an implicit admission that achieving the targets of Vision 2030 will be difficult, Crown Prince Muhammad bin Salman is ploughing ahead with reforms. At the same time, any criticism of royal rule is being firmly rebuffed. Dealing with immediate threats to royal rule, however, may leave Muhammad exposed to challenge on another front.

by Senior Analyst Talal Kapoor

News that Saudi Arabia's proposed share-sale of state-owned oil giant Aramco may be in trouble seems to fit a recent pattern, in which lofty dreams of a wholesale reshaping of society have come crashing to earth. From the inception of the ambitious Vision 2030, the brainchild of Crown Prince Muhammad bin Salman, brutal economic realities have combined with an entrenched mentality of government entitlement to put the brakes on any hopes that the project would enjoy a smooth ride. From the beginning, some economists called into question the very attainability of the targets, while others turned a skeptical eye on the jargon-filled technocratic advice given by hired American firms. There was further concern over opening up the books on the opaque Saudi Aramco, whose proposed sale (in part) represented a key component of the plan. But the size of the offering itself, compounded by legal questions, has now thrown into doubt the ability of the London exchange, at least, to manage the project.

This would be only the latest setback to Muhammad's plan. Earlier, the government was forced to backtrack from measures to cap salaries and reduce benefits for civil servants, after a major outcry. Given that the essence of Vision 2030 is a move to a post-oil economy, with a greater reliance on the private sector to provide employment, this was a significant setback, highlighting the difficulty Saudi will have in weaning a citizenry long accustomed to government largesse off their high expectations. Low oil prices, the mainstay of the national economy, will need to recover to a much greater extent if the Kingdom's economy is to be put back on an even keel. The immediate danger, despite the clear need for drastic change if long term economic health is to be realised, is that the people will lack the patience to see the project through. In a country where many regard a government job for life as a birthright, and subsidies for education and health care are taken for granted, imposing the discipline for a shift away from a culture of entitlement may be the greatest challenge.

Dissatisfaction with the measures being implemented by the crown prince, however, risk rupturing the unstated social contract between citizens and royals, whereby political acquiescence is expected in return for economic welfare and stability. An extended period of low energy prices, combined with an inability to meet the targets of Vision 2030 (as well as its dependent shorter term goals) could bring social instability and challenges to royal rule. It is unclear how seriously Muhammad takes these concerns, or whether he believes a campaign to crack down on dissent is sustainable indefinitely. So far, he seems confident in his ability to carry through the proposed reforms, whilst swatting away any perceived criticism. How far a heavy-handed approach will work in the face of general and sustained economic discontent is an open question. The Al Saud are nothing if not adaptable and politically agile, but this would be uncharted territory. During the Arab Spring, the first signs of political activism were easily bought off by King Abdallah; empty coffers would render the same tactic impossible in another case.

Thus far, intolerance for dissent has taken the form of a crackdown on two flanks - the religious establishment and relatively secular liberals. Both paid the price for implied criticism of Saudi policies last month, when a security sweep netted a number of high-profile clerics, intellectuals, and scholars, each of whom had apparently questioned the wisdom or motive of recent government decisions. In the short term, such silencing will have the desired effect - the authorities have the upper hand and the backing of the majority, who are weary of overbearing religious discipline but for the most part view Western liberal ideas with suspicion. Unaccounted for, is the broader impact of an authoritarian policy in an economic downturn.

Related articles: The Islamist Crackdown: Impending Autocracy Or Crumbling Support?
Changing Family Dynamics: End of an Interlude?
For access to the rest of this article, as well as the Datarabia archive, subscribe to the Royal Family Directory. Subscribe
Page 2: a dangerous gambit?
Top 5 Royal Biographies

Al Walid bin Talal
Abdallah bin Abd al-Aziz
Salman bin Abd al-Aziz
Sultan bin Abd al-Aziz
Nayif bin Abdallah

Search:

Past Feature Articles
The Islamist Crackdown: Impending Autocracy Or Crumbling Support?

The month of September got under way with an alarming crackdown on dissent which targeted critics of the newly-installed crown prince, Muhammad bin Salman. At the same time as he scales back plans for the ambitious Vision 2030, the crown prince is moving to solidify his position. But do his aggressive tactics underline how tenuous his position really is, or rather, do they expose an overconfident belief that he can navigate the treacherous waters alone?

Changing Family Dynamics: End of an Interlude?

As traditional assumptions about the place of consensus, seniority and compromise in domestic family politics are cast aside in the face of new realities, any discussion of succession must take into account the evolving dynamics. The more recent history of the Al Saud, in fact, and the impression drawn of of stability, practicality, and quiet competence, may, in the larger scheme, prove more the exception than the rule.

Succession Shock - The Trump Effect?

The King has replaced Crown Prince Muhammad bin Nayif with his own son, Muhammad, the deputy crown prince and defense minister, in a move which, though not entirely unexpected, represents a seismic shift in the succession dynamic. Now, the position of deputy crown prince remains vacant - will Salman abdicate in favor of his son, and who will be next in line?

The End of Consensus: Uncharted Terrain?

The rapid promotion of King Salman's son, Muhammad, highlights a fundamental contrast between the king and his predecessor. In the matter of succession, owing to his position within the royal family and a different outlook resulting from that advantage, Salman can afford to downplay the role of consensus and effect a radical break from the past.

The Death of Prince Mish'al - Demise of the Allegiance Committee?

With the death of Prince Mish'al, Chairman of the Allegiance Commission - the formal entity established to decide succession matters - King Salman has an opportunity to reconstitute the body and restore its relevancy at a time of great uncertainty over the role of his favorite son, the controversial Muhammad, who serves as deputy crown prince. It is a course of action Salman is unlikely to take.

More